Talk:Herbalism

Spawn Time of Herbs
Can someone please add information about the respawn time for herbs? --Somebody

I've been looking for this data on the wiki and can't find it either. I initially looked in Herbs, but also think it'd be appropriate here. Do all resources have the same spawn time algorithm? Maybe it should be mentioned on Resource or in Professions. --Radeex (talk) 03:36, 21 June 2009 (UTC)

by Ability Level
Would anyone mind if I combine all of these into one table, with heads at the top of the appropriate section? I'll do just that, and if anyone minds, they can change it back. -- D. F. Schmidt talk 15:17, 22 Aug 2005 (EDT)
 * Strike that. I tried it for a minute, and it looked terrible. -- D. F. Schmidt talk 15:33, 22 Aug 2005 (EDT)

I think it would be hot if we could have a table like so:

If someone has the data I will make the table myself. - Zuel 22:08, 15 March 2006 (EST)

Bloodvine
I understand that this drops in ZG, but Herbalism required to harvest this? To the best of my knowledge this requires only a special scythe and therefore may not fall under the herbalism category. Any thoughtd or further information? Moosephat 14:17, 21 April 2006 (EDT)

Yes, it does require Herbalism. Bloodvine doesnt grow by itself. Rather it is parasitic, meaning that you find it within other herb nodes. Swiftthistle works the same way. - Azh 15:32, 21 April 2006 (EDT)

The Bloodvine and Blood Scythe articles should answer your question, Moosephat.

Tidywave 16:23, 21 April 2006 (EDT)

Herb Table
Starting the above mentioned table... doing it in the 'background' for editing til more data is entered...

I Wont put in the herb locations, IMO there are way too many to list in a table of this fashion... Peacebloom, for example, is in about 12? areas.. at least...
 * 1) = Swiftthistle "piggy backs" on Briarthorn and Mageroyal, you can obtain it when you can pick Briarthorn or Mageroyal


 * 1) = Wildvine, like swiftthistle, if found inside Purple Lotus patches


 * 1) = Bloodvine is a Raid-level herb, its only found in Zul'Grub when a Blood Scyth is equiped, and is found inside other Herbs within the zone.

* = Black Lotus is extremely rare and hard to find. It requires 300 herbalism skill and is still hard to pick (will get a failed attempt now and then), the Herbalism enchant will reduce failure rates on this and other herbs. --Kewi 15:37, 7 July 2006 (EDT)

Guide
I've removed the external link to the herbalism guide because it is inaccurate and is just a gateway to gold/guide selling sites

I'd suggest removing all other links to that site

Herb percentages
On the pages that exist for an individual herb (briarthorn) there is a list of pickable locations with percentages after them. I believe this requires an explanation of what they mean and a statement or citation explaining where the information was got from. Could someone (preferably the person who added it in the first place) please put that information in? DuTempete (talk) 15:56, 3 June 2009 (UTC)
 * I was the one who did that for most of the herbs. It was the thottbot sightings data at the time it was created. Note that the object you click on to herb is different data from the herb that appears in your inventory. is the briarthorn data for example and was a straight copy/paste. However the numbers I listed were a quick and dirty way of coming up with the percentages since it's thottbot sightings and not the absolute for the zone. (I thought it was the absolute number at the time, and not weighted by popularity. Unpopular zones skew the % results, when really it shoudn't as it's not a chance but an absolute.)


 * There are only X number of spawn locations total for resource nodes like herbs. A better way is to take each zone # of spawn locations (which isn't the same as drops) and divided it by the total # across all zones = % by zone. This is a known number and available on wowhead and doesn't change. (Briarthorn again ). I wanted to include all this info at the time, but I didn't know how to make a chart on a wiki. It looked too messy any way I could do it, so I used the simplified info. Since then I've learned (and now forgotten) how to make wiki charts. I agree that adding the number of possible spawns by zone is useful information, but I will not be the one adding that info.
 * Hmm I just had an idea. Instead of "Pickable Zones" come up with a more informative title and include the total number of spawn locations for all of Azeroth for each herb. Example: "This herb has (X) spawn locations, they are in:" Then if someone cares how many spawns are specifically in Duskwood for example, they can multiply (X) by the listed percentage.--Brunpal (talk) 12:57, 18 July 2009 (UTC)

XP Table
I have added an XP Table. The table is a bit hard to read, so some changes in the appearance must be made. Hans Kamp (talk) 11:05, 25 October 2010 (UTC)
 * Personally, I think it needs to be removed from the page altogether. Its taking up too much room, and its only going to get massively larger with another ~50 levels, and many more herbs added.  Is there a specific reason we need this chart?  This of course goes for Mining as well.  I'd rather it say something like "Herbing/Mining gives users different XP on gather depending on the level of the herb/node, and your proficiency in said gathering skill."  Shouldn't that be sufficient? Ressy (talk) 21:47, 29 November 2010 (UTC)
 * I have been thinking about it now... I could make a table for each herb, instead of a general table like there is now. The table will be gigantic, when I continue this way on my way to level 85. The same for Mining. Hans Kamp (talk) 12:13, 4 December 2010 (UTC)