Talk:Fish

Removed the 'Catchable fish' table. It was covered better on the Fishing items page, and having two tables is twice as much to synchronize and maintain. The 'Catchable fish' table was very incomplete, and had numerous errors. I did pick out the few key facts that were on the 'Catchable fish' table and not in the Fishing items page and put them in the Fishing items page.

Moving the 'food fish' from the 'Catchable fish' page to the 'food fish' page obfuscates what can be caught while fishing. Linking to the 'Catchable fish' page works, because not only is what can be caught while fishing clear, and which ones are food is clear, but which ones can be used as food in odd cases (primarly for pets) is noted in a fair amount of detail on the 'Catchable fish' page.

This leaves core text explaining fish as food in WoW and where to obtain it, ... and a table.

I considered moving the 'Types of buyable fish' table to the Fish vendors page. It fits better where it is, in my opinion, although neither seems ideal. It does not seem to warrant it's own page, and it does describe an aspect of fish as food.

Note that there is also no consolidation of 'fish food that drops from mobs' data.

Madkaugh (talk) 04:34, 3 June 2008 (UTC)
 * Lawl, I had no idea either page existed. --Notmyhandle (talk) 10:28, 3 June 2008 (UTC)