Talk:Jewelcrafting leveling guide 1-450

On building a better guide
--Eirik Ratcatcher (talk) 20:46, November 17, 2009 (UTC)
 * 1) Killing the previous guide, then flagging for help on the new guide seems kinda silly to me, to be honest.  Having the new guide shaped up first seems more sensible, if one goes that way.
 * 2) I'd prefer not completely ditching the Guide to leveling jewelcrafting to 300.  See my comments there.
 * 3) If nothing else, consider duplicating the ingredients format from that page.  The table format for what recipes to use is modestly useful.
 * 4) Breaking the materials needed into sections by skill level is also useful.

Wikified a bit
I went ahead and wikified the links, as well as linked back to the previous jewelcrafting guide. However, it seems like this page is a copy of

http://www.wow-professions.com/wowguides/wow_jewelcrafting_leveling_guide.html.

Needs rewrite
This is definitely a rip-off of the Wow-professions guide referenced above. Same wording. Same errors. If this is to be the Wowwiki guide, it needs a total rewrite from the ground up. In other words, write a new one. I like the economical guide format of the previous guide. Draconthir (talk) 16:52, September 13, 2010 (UTC)