User talk:Whisperwind1

why are you putting the Warcraft I, II, III Units/Classes category on all of the World of Warcraft class pages? I could see how that would be revelvant if those pages said anything about any of those three games but they dont.

first off please sign your posts so people know who's talking, secondly you mentioned hunter so let's go with that, I read the entire hunter lore page which you tagged with this category and it never mentions any of those games, nor those classes apearing as a unit in any of them. I just don't see how that page, not hunter as a class. is part of the category. categories contain things that discuss them. that page, nor any of the others you tagged does. If you want to write a page about hunters units in those games (if there isn't one already) then that would be awsome! And the perfect thing for that category, i can't see how these pages are though.

shadow hunter or Demon Hunter would be things that fit in your category.

umm off the top of my head... shaman rogue and warrior, those pages, really don't have anything to do with the warcraft 1, 2, 3 games. On second thought i don't really see a reason against the lore pages being tagged with this as it is the same lore, not a strong reason for but not a reason against. pretty much the main pages of all the WoW classes i would say dont' belong here. just imho though.


 * um, basicly saying i don't know lol. Personally i wouldn't keep them, and i don't think there really is a strong argument to keep them as they don't directly relate. What would be a good idea i think is if you linked them on pages that were about hunter mages, etc in 1,2,3. ie. put a link of the bottom of Mage (Warcraft II) that says something to the effect of "for lore on mages see ____". basicly i don't think they deserve to be in the category but i think they would be useful links for things in the category if that makes sense.

Unit Stats
Unit stats from the RTS games, RPG, or even WoW should not be in class or lore articles. For example stats for units in Warcraft I should remain in a Warcraft units article, similar to the Warcraft II Units article. Thanks in advance.Baggins 18:56, 13 May 2007 (EDT)