Talk:C'Thun

Archived discussions: Talk:C'Thun/Archive01

Dead
Back on the Deceased status (again).

Please tell me who can hear him, and in what comic does it happen (I do not have the comics beyond the 16th). So we can make a proper citation/reference, because for now we read "Deafeated "the old god is dead", which is a small contradiction as defeated and deceased are two separate things.

07:13, April 12, 2010 (UTC)


 * Med'an hears him whispering in one of the comics, but the comics also tell us explicitly that C'Thun is dead. I think the easiest rationale is that death for an Old God isn't quite what it is for mortals. -- Dark T Zeratul (talk) 22:02, April 12, 2010 (UTC)


 * Probably no different than the loa. Har'koa states that death is not the end for an eternal, or something like that. 23:55, April 12, 2010 (UTC)


 * I would said that his body is dead-like but he is still alive in spirit type.


 * That why we should put him as defeated for the Lore, because he is not dead dead. C'Thun order Cho'gall to kidnapped Med'an. The reason why C'Thun want Med'an is because he need a new host and Med'an is a "beacon of power". Because Cho'gall try to resurrect C'Thun's body by using Med'an's body, and the boy was saved by Valeera Sanguinar and other people, the magic of resurrection backfire and merge Cho'gall and C'Thun as one being. C'Thun still whisper Med'an in order to fix the problem by bringing the boy alone to Ahn'Qiraj. Med'an did not fall into the trap that C'Thun try to set up.


 * I am trying choose the right word because C'Thun was not dead but his body was. Cho'gall was just trying to merge and remove Med'an's spirit for the Old God. So i do not think that is a resurrection spell we would think of. I do agree it is a resurrection spell of some type.


 * That why C'Thun should be listed as defeated because he was never killed. 9:59, April 12, 2010 (MT)

Prophecy of C'Thun mistake
One Old God was killed during the battle and its remains can be seen at the Master's Glaive in Darkshore with an immense sword piercing its skull. Three were weakened while C'Thun fell into the barren lands of Silithus - but did not die.

I think this part is a mistake.

If you read the Prophecy of C'Thun, you would find this "a battle between a Titan and a being of unimaginable evil and power raged on this very soil". "This very soil" is talking about Silithus since the creator of the prophecy, Prophet Skeram, was born and raise in Silithus. Therefore it is a battle between C'Thun and a titan. If you look at the area where C'Thun is found, there is no titan marks like Uldaman, Ulduar, and Uldum. I would said C'Thun is one of the two Old Gods listed by the titans as dead.

That battle against the Titan did weaken C'Thun to a point that he was very near death however he did cause a titan to fall. The other titans did not know he was still alive, then attack the other Old Gods. When the Titans did kill the second Old God, their "computer" tell them that killing the Old God would destroy Azeroth. The Titan change their plan and choose to imprison the last three Old God. C'Thun was never imprison and became a power-lord during the Troll Empires, before the War of the Ancients.

In the Prophecy of C'Thun, it never said anything about Master's Glaive. In fact the Master's Glaive is a site where it is believed that a titan killed one of the Old Gods or one of their minions there. We need to fix the info in couple post; Master's Glaive, C'Thun, and Old Gods. C'Thun was the weakest Old Gods of Azeroth however he did kill a titan. 9:07 am, July 7, 2010 (MT)

Mostly Dead
According to 4.1.0 and Total Biscuit, C'Thun is still alive and you see a vision of him (one of his eyes). When you click on him he says "HI!" Hallowseve15 (talk) 00:55, 18 March 2011 (UTC)
 * I watched his video,He didn't say C'thun is alive,what you see is Vision of C'thun,and it could happen in the past,wait for the quest to be finished becuase you make statements.[[Image:IconSmall_HighElf_Male.gif]] Aesindor, The Celestial Paladin (Leave a Message) 17:35, 18 March 2011 (UTC)