User talk:DScharff24/WarCraftIV: The Return of the RTS

Some ideas are good, especially randomness of races. It still lacks good story, but some game mechanics are good. Work on it and it should be good.

About the story, Legion once again and Illidari are... well, pretty lame. Illidan is dead in WoW:tBC and Akama reclaimed the Temple of Karabor "to the Light". And Legion... I bet we would finally deal with Sargeras himself in the last expansion of WoW, so you should better find another villain.

My grade for this: 4-/6. Severin Andrews 18:12, 18 June 2008 (UTC)

Thanks for the overall rating. I think I'm just going to ax the Illidari, for now. I'll put it back on if I can think of some better lore. However, I may keep the Legion in there (again, with better lore, like why they decided to return to Azeroth) until we find out for sure if the Legion is defeated (even though it's almost certain that it will, Bliz could always decide to have you face them down in a new RTS, like the one I was thinking of). 04:59, 17 July 2008 (UTC)